Full body scanners unreliable to use, Germany says

Do Body Scanners Work?


Photographer: WXYZ
Copyright 2011 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Full-body scanner_20101118170733_JPG

An airline passenger undergoes a full body scan at O'Hare International Airport Wednesday, Nov. 17, 2010 in Chicago. (AP Photo/Charles Rex Arbogast)

Advertisement

Posted: 09/02/2011

The German government has stopped the roll out of full body scanners in the country's airports.  It says they simply create too many false alarms.

After a series of tests, German officials say the new scanners have a false alarm rate of nearly 50 percent, including mistaking underarm sweats for a dangerous chemical.

About 250 full body scanners are currently in use at dozens of U.S. airports including Detroit Metro. They cost about $170 thousand a piece.

Folks who have protested the scanners due to privacy concerns about the detailed images they provide say this is evidence they should not be used.

"The German experience has demonstrated exactly how ineffective the devices are.  When they can't distinguish between body sweat and explosives, or the pleats of someone's pants and an underwear bomb- they're not making anyone safer," said John Verdi of the Electronic Privacy Information Center.

The TSA tells ABC News it will not comment on Germany's decision or study of the scanners.

Copyright 2011 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

  • Comments
  • Marketplace
Advertisement

Top Stories


  1. Middle school music program needs help

    Middle school music program needs help

    Donorschoose.org is a website that will allow private donors to give directly to the school of their choice. Detroit Merit Charter Academy administrators have turned to facebook and other sites to get help for their struggling music program.

  2. Looks like candy? Laundry packet warning

    Looks like candy? Laundry packet warning

    Parents are being urged to keep laundry detergent packets out of reach of young children after several children have been sickened nationwide.

  3. Keeping Grandmont-Rosedale vibrant

    Keeping Grandmont-Rosedale vibrant

    As we continue our look at efforts to control blight across the area, a non-profit group is taking the lead in northwest Detroit.