Michigan law gives some lawsuit immunity to pharmaceutical companies

Wife can't sue after husband's death


Photographer: WXYZ
Copyright 2012 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Advertisement

Posted: 07/27/2012

 

Five years ago Sheila Muniz says her husband Eddie  made a decision that would change her family forever.  He asked a doctor for psoriasis medicine.

The doctor prescribed him Raptiva, a drug made by Genentech.

"His skin started to turn a bit of yellow,  jaundiced. We went to our doctor, and then the emergency room.  He never left," said Sheila Muniz.

Muniz says the drug shut down her husband's kidneys and liver.  The previously healthy dad died at 38-years-old, weeks after starting the medication.

"There is no healing from this I will suffer from this until the day I die," said Sheila Muniz.

 Eddie Muniz wasn't the only person who died after taking Raptiva.  In 2009 the FDA sent out a statement announcing that the maker took the drug  off the market because it was dangerous.

When Muniz tried to sue,several attorneys turned her away because  she is from Michigan.  Michigan law gives  pharmaceutical companies immunity from lawsuits connected to FDA approved drugs.

"Its ridiculous," said attorney Alyson Oliver. "It is insane to think that a company isn't held accountable."

Oliver took Muniz's case because she says it is the right thing to do.  The case is currently before the Michigan Court of Appeals.  Oliver says the case gives Muniz a voice, but it may or may not give her justice due to Michigan's unique law.

As for why the law giving pharmaceutical companies some immunity exists, it was meant to encourage drug companies to invest in Michigan.  It was also meant to prevent frivolous lawsuits.

Rep. Lisa Brown, D-West Bloomfield, says it didn't work.  Drug companies have moved many jobs out of Michigan in recent years.  She says lawmakers need to protect residents, not pharmaceutical companies.

"I have gotten calls from people around Michigan," says Brown. "They say my son has been hurt. My husband has been hurt.I have been hurt. What can i do? There is no recourse that they can have."

Representative Brown says she has introduced a bill that would take away legal immunity from pharmaceutical companies.  She says she is struggling to get the bill to move forward in the legislative process.  She is asking residents to contact their representatives if they want the law changed.

Sheila Muniz says she hopes it is passed in time for her to get justice for her husband. 

"Nobody is protected right now.  Any pharmaceutical company can do anything to you,and get away with it," said Muniz.

Seven Action News called Genentech and its attorneys.  They had no comment on Michigan law or the the case filed by Sheila Muniz.

Copyright 2012 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

  • Comments
 
Advertisement

More Oakland County News


  1. Man appears in court after golf incident

    Man appears in court after golf incident

    The victim of a golf course attack says he was beaten after asking what the score was.

  2. World's Most Expensive Wine comes to MI

    World's Most Expensive Wine comes to MI

    The world’s most expensive wine made an appearance in Bloomfield Hills Tuesday afternoon.

    • INTERVIEW: Hoffa tipster speaks out

      INTERVIEW: Hoffa tipster speaks out

      The man whose tip prompted this latest search for Jimmy Hoffa’s remains is saying he’s frustrated that nothing has been found yet.