Site Tools: RSS | Email Alerts | Mobile
Print this Story
Set Text Size SmallSet Text Size MediumSet Text Size LargeSet Text Size X-Large

Day Care Workers Fight Union


Last Update: 10/18/2009 5:04 pm
(WXYZ) -  Most people who launch their own business believe they call the shots because they are the boss.  That's what Paulette Silverson thought too when she launched a home daycare out of her Brighton home 12 years ago.  It's called Wondercare.

When she learned she was being forced into a union she was flabbergasted. 

She received a postcard that said she was now a dues paying member of the United Auto Workers.

That means the union is taking a cut out of every state issued check to home day care providers of low income children whose parents need help paying for child care.

Paulette wants to know how they can come in and take money from businesses that are provately owned and turn them into union members.

Silverson is not alone.  In December, 2008, 40,000 home daycare owners were notified by mail that they were now members of the newly formed Child Care Providers Together Michigan union.

It's a joint enterprise of United Auto Workers and the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees.

Patrick Wright of the Mackinac Center Legal Foundation just filed a lawsuit in September on behalf of two home daycare owners, Sherry Loar and Dawn Ives.

Sherry says she doesn't remember receiving anything other than notification that they were going to start removing funds from any co-payment she received from the State of Michigan.

Patrick Wright says similar unionizing efforts are underway in 8 or 10 states.  He calculates that adds up to 400-thousand new members and $37-million dodllars in dues and that really starts to add up.

Sarida Moss is a UAW Region One servicing rep. for Child Care Providers Together Michigan.  She says for three years union reps went door to door, sent letters and called providers to educate them about a possible union.

So, how do independent business owners become union members?  Well, it is complicated and tricky.

In July of 2006, the Department of Human Services signed an agreement with Mott Community College to form the Michigan Home Based Child Care Council.

By November of 2006, the Michigan Employment Relations Commission conducted a vote by mail.  Of the more than 40-thousand home daycare providers in Michigan, only a little more than 6-thousand voted.

Wright says Loar and Ives don't believe they were aware of the vote to become unionized, and did not vote.
Silverson says, "I have to admit I did not read the fine print and didn't look into it.  I just checked a big No and stuck it in the mailbox.."

In some rural areas people were against the union.  For every 25 people who said yes, 75 said no.  However, Moss says once people are educated about what the union does they come around.

Loar called her state representative to complain.  She got nowhere.  They she says she wrote Governor Jennifer Granholm.  Twice.  The second time by registered mail.  No response.

When we called the Governor's office, we were told the matter is under litigation and there would be no comment.

Some home daycare providers admit they have very few children whose payments are subsidized by the state.  Still, they say every dollar counts.

Their lawyer hopes this will be taken care of before things really get out of hand, "Are we going to do doctors next because they take Medicare? Are we going to do landlords next because there's rent assistance?  Are we going to do small grocers next because there's food stamps?  Where does this end and why are we doing it?

Silverson says for now, she's dealing with it and doesn't have the heart to charge her parents another dime but she says, "I hope the lawsuit can stop it.  I hope they can un-unionize all of us home daycare owners."

The Michigan Department of Human Services has gone to court asking that the daycare workers suit be thrown out.
Patrick Wright has until later this month to respond to that request.
WANTED! Your Snow Photos & Video
We want to see what you capture throughout the storm. You can upload your pics and video right to our site!
ALERT: I-94 Closed Near Ypsilanti Twp.
Both directions of I-94 are closed at Michigan Avenue in Washtenaw County because of an injury accident.
Volunteers Needed
Volunteers are needed to shovel snow for seniors in Oakland and Livingston counties.
Little Girl With A Big Spirit
She has a small body, but an enormous heart and spirit. Ten years ago Carolyn Clifford reported on a boy with progeria. Now, she introduces us to a very special little girl with the same rare disease. Video Watch Video
Trip Trouble: Emergency Health Problems
The Call for Action team goes to work for a 70-year-old Detroit woman who suffered an emergency health problem just days before she was scheduled to fly to Atlanta. Video Watch Video


Did you see breaking news?
Call our Breaking News Hotline
(248) 827-9407
Or click to send us an email

Snow Alert: Winter Storm Warning in Effect!
There is a Winter Storm Warning in effect for all of southeast Michigan through 10:00 a.m. Wednesday. INSIDE: Continuous Forecast Updates Video Watch Video
Mother Arraigned in Son's Stabbing
A 25-year-old mother who is accused of stabbing her 1-year-old son three times was charged Friday afternoon with assault with intent to commit murder. Video Watch Video
Pastor Charged With Criminal Sexual Conduct
A 35-year-old pastor is facing six counts of criminal sexual conduct after being arrested over the weekend. Video Watch Video
ALERT: I-94 Reopens After School Bus Crash
The eastbound lanes of I-94 near Livernois are now back open after an accident involving a school bus and a car.
Man Tasered After Airport Security Breach
A man is in police custody after officials say he was tasered while running through a security checkpoint at Metro Airport's McNamara Terminal. Video Watch Video
Entertainment Headlines
Stern confirms Idol gossip
Shock jock Howard Stern has confirmed reports he has been approached to replace Simon Cowell when the British music mogul quits American Idol.
'24' finally heading to the big screen
Kiefer Sutherland's dream of bringing 24 to cinemas is set to come true.
New tweeter Parker sends fans to porn site
Eva Longoria Parker gave online fans a saucy shock after joining Twitter.
De Rossi writing tell-all book
Ellen DeGeneres' wife Portia De Rossi is set to lift the lid on her private life with a tell-all book which will include her struggles with her sexuality and harrowing details of her battle with anorexia.
Mueller moving back in with Sheen
Brooke Mueller is moving back in with her husband Charlie Sheen, according to her lawyer.
National / World
Another wintry mess headed east
Mother nature is getting ready to drop a new snowy mess over the top of the one deposited over the weekend.
Toyota makes Prius recall for brake fix
Toyota says it is recalling about 437,000 Prius and other hybrid vehicles worldwide to fix brake problems, the latest in a string of embarrassing safety problems at the world's largest automaker.
Astronauts inspect shuttle on way to space station
Things look good aboard the shuttle. A few pieces of foam insulation did break off the external fuel tank during launch, but there's no indication anything hit the shuttle.
Fires strike two more east Texas churches
A sheriff's dispatcher says fires have struck two more rural east Texas churches, just hours after investigators announced that a blaze last week marked the eighth arson against a house of worship in the state this year.
Man rescued after three days in snow-covered SUV in Colorado
A 31-year-old Indiana man says he didn't have food but kept himself hydrated with Mountain Dew and snow while he was stuck in his snow-covered SUV in southwestern Colorado for three days.


  This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.