She was terminated from her position by the Attorney General and she was at the center of a 7 Action News investigation. So why are taxpayers now paying the salary of this local lawyer?
A criminal investigation was launched after we exposed how some public officials and real estate brokers were cashing in on probate estates, often leaving rightful heirs with very little.
- 7 Action News Investigation prompts probate law change, protects heirs
- Probate public officials terminated, resign after 7 Action News investigation
- Attorney General, Chief Probate Judge want new rules in wake of 7 Action News Investigation
- AG suspends Macomb probate public administrator, leaders want law changed
So why is one of the public officials being investigated by Oakland County -- now working for Oakland County’s Probate Court?
The 7 Investigators first exposed probate attorney Barbara Andruccioli a year ago.
“How can the taxpayers have any confidence with you working here,” asked 7 Investigator Heather Catallo.
“Really, I think you probably need to talk to the judges,” said Andruccioli.
Andruccioli was a partner at Kemp Klein law firm. She was also an Attorney General-appointed Public Administrator: a public official with the authority to open probate estates after someone dies if there are no heirs available.
Court records show Andruccioli teamed up with real estate broker Ralph Roberts and his companies to open those estates, sell the homes, and cash in.
We uncovered court filings that show Andruccioli and one of Roberts’ companies, Probate Asset Recovery, were billing for thousands of dollars, while the actual heirs ended up with very little.
“They should be held accountable,” Joanne Zaremba told Catallo in 2017.
Until the 7 Investigators got involved, Zaremba had no idea that Andruccioli had opened an estate in her late mother’s name, even though under the law, Andruccioli had a duty to find the heirs.
After our investigation, Attorney General Bill Schuette terminated Andruccioli as a Public Administrator. And that’s not all: the FBI and Oakland County Sheriff’s detectives raided Ralph Roberts offices, and launched a criminal probe into the Public Administrators.
So why did the Oakland County Probate judges recently hire Andruccioli as the Probate Register for the county?
“How can the taxpayers have any confidence -- when you’re now under criminal investigation -- with you working in this court,” asked Catallo.
"That’s not true,” said Andruccioli.
“It struck me as the wolf guarding the hen house,” said Oakland County Treasurer Andy Meisner.
Oakland County Clerk Lisa Brown described her reaction when she first heard that the judges from the Probate Court (which Brown and Meisner do not oversee) hired Andruccioli: “Shock, absolute shock and bewilderment… So out of having a wonderful pool of applicants, why would you choose this person who has a cloud over them?”
In the wake of our reporting, Brown and Meisner successfully fought to change the state laws that allowed this probate practice to go on. Two bills sponsored by Rep. Jim Runestad (R-White Lake) and Rep. Jim Ellison (D-Royal Oak) were signed into law in February.
Neither Meisner nor Brown can understand why the four Oakland County Probate judges would hire Andruccioli.
“It’s natural that people that work together are going to get to know each other and establish relationships,” said Meisner. “The unusual part is when those relationships and friendships result in inappropriate preference, self-dealing, and lack of due process.”
The Probate Register oversees the daily operations of the Probate Courts Estates and Mental Health division.
Chief Probate Judge Kathleen Ryan would not talk to us on camera, but she did tell 7 Action News that the decision to hire Andruccioli as the Probate Register of the court was unanimous among all four judges and she said, “we’re confident in our hire.”
Judge Ryan also confirmed they hired Andruccioli at the top of the county pay scale, at $102,650. Also, in the past Andruccioli has given small campaign contributions to two of the judges who hired her (Judge Ryan and Judge Jennifer Callaghan), but Judge Ryan says that had no bearing on the hiring decision.
“I think it is a slap in the face to a lot of people,” said Brown. “It reduces confidence that justice will be served here.”
Officials from both the Oakland County Prosecutor’s office and Sheriff’s office tell the 7 Investigators that the criminal probe into the probate scheme and the Public Administrators is ongoing.
County officials such as the Clerk, the Treasurer and the County Executive do not have control over who the judges hire.
If you have a story for Heather, please email her at firstname.lastname@example.org or call 248-827-4473.